Grammar Isn’t Enough: The Truth About Bad Writing Advice and What Great Tutors Teach

Most people think writing tutors spend their time fixing commas and pointing out grammar mistakes. But here’s the truth: Good writing doesn’t start with grammar. It starts with thinking—deep, critical, creative thinking. And that’s where great writing tutors make all the difference. Too often, students fall victim to bad writing advice, like focusing solely on grammar or relying on rigid formulas, which stifles creativity and authentic expression.

Writing Isn’t About the First Draft

The first draft is only the beginning. It’s where the ideas take shape, but writing truly happens in the revisions. This is where students learn to analyze their thoughts, add depth to their arguments, and refine their unique voices.

Great tutors don’t just look for grammatical errors—they help students think on paper. By guiding students through the recursive process of brainstorming, drafting, and revising, tutors teach them how to communicate effectively and authentically.

Teaching Critical Thinking Through Writing

Many students think writing is about following formulas or ticking off grammar rules, but the heart of writing lies in critical thinking. Good writing tutors challenge students to ask big questions, think from different perspectives, and articulate their ideas clearly.

Take, for example, a student I recently worked with on his college essay. At first glance, his draft seemed polished—free of grammar mistakes and neatly written. But it lacked authenticity, voice, and a connection to the prompt. Together, we dove deeper into his experiences, using thought-provoking questions to uncover the story behind the list of achievements.

The result? A personal, compelling essay that truly reflected who he was—and answered the college’s prompt.

Beyond Grammar: What Writing Tutors Really Teach

Here’s what great writing tutors focus on:

Building Ideas: Helping students develop their arguments, narratives, and points of view.
Finding Voice: Encouraging students to write authentically and expressively.
Analyzing Texts: Teaching students to read critically, so they can identify what works and why.
Crafting Structure: Guiding students to organize their thoughts and present them logically.
Strengthening Confidence: Supporting students through the challenging process of revision.

By focusing on these deeper aspects of writing, tutors don’t just teach students how to write—they teach them how to think, communicate, and grow.

Why Writing Is a Lifelong Skill

Writing isn’t just for school essays or college applications. It’s a skill that serves students in every area of life—from academic success to career advancement.

Surprisingly, many careers rely heavily on writing skills, even those that don’t seem directly connected to language or literature. Fields like engineering, healthcare, data analysis, and software development often require clear, concise communication. Writing reports, documenting research, drafting proposals, or explaining complex concepts to non-experts are daily tasks in these professions.

Even creative and technical roles like graphic design, UX/UI design, and marketing rely on the ability to write well—whether it’s crafting compelling copy for campaigns or documenting project objectives for clients and team members.

One of my former students returned to visit me after graduating from college and completing the police academy. He shared how much he relied on the writing skills he’d honed during our sessions—particularly when drafting police reports.

He explained that a well-written report, with clear expression and proper grammar, could make or break a case. Judges and legal teams often rely on the details in these reports to make life-altering decisions, impacting safety, justice, and lives.

The weight of his words had real consequences, and he was grateful for the tools he had learned to communicate effectively in such high-stakes situations.

How Writing Helps in Math and Sciences

Strong writing skills don’t just benefit students in English class—they’re critical in subjects like math and science as well. Here’s how:

Clarifying Complex Ideas: In math, students often need to explain their reasoning or document problem-solving steps clearly. Writing helps them organize their thoughts and present solutions logically.
Building Analytical Thinking: Writing teaches students to break down concepts and identify connections—a skill that’s essential for understanding scientific theories and presenting lab reports.
Communicating Discoveries: Whether it’s a science fair presentation or a college research paper, writing helps students articulate findings effectively and persuasively.

When students learn to write well, they’re not just improving their communication skills—they’re enhancing their ability to solve problems, think critically, and succeed in any academic discipline.

Walk Away From Bad Writing Advice

Writing tutors aren’t grammar mechanics; we’re coaches, mentors, and collaborators. We help students unlock the power of their own thoughts and turn them into meaningful, impactful writing.

By steering students away from bad writing advice and showing them how to think critically, we give them tools to communicate with confidence and clarity.

Unlock the Power of Your Student’s Writing!

GET WRITING SUPPORT

Great writing starts with great thinking. Let’s move beyond grammar and build real skills in critical thinking, expression, and confidence.